Does Medical Error Disclosure Violate the Medical Malpractice Insurance Cooperation Clause?
نویسنده
چکیده
Medical malpractice insurance policies customarily contain a “cooperation” clause requiring insureds to cooperate with the insurer’s efforts to defend the insured against a claim. A common stipulation in this clause forbids the insured from “admitting liability” to an injured or harmed party. Health professionals often understand this clause to have a chilling effect on the truthful disclosure of medical error, which is morally required of physicians when they know that a harm-causing error has occurred. This paper offers a two-part response to the fear that medical error disclosure might result in a denial of malpractice insurance coverage. Part one describes various legal precedents wherein insurers successfully invoked the cooperation clause to deny coverage in instances of liability admission. This paper shows, however, that the legally sanctioned reasons for denying coverage in these cases address factors other than an insured’s truthful and honest disclosure of what happened to a claimant. Consequently, these cases do not support the belief that legal precedents discourage the truthful disclosure of harm-causing medical errors. Part two of this paper proposes that the cooperation clause’s prohibition of admission of liability in instances of medical error disclosure might well be unenforceable, and that the clause might not even be actuarially sound.
منابع مشابه
US and Canadian physicians' attitudes and experiences regarding disclosing errors to patients.
BACKGROUND Patients are often not told about harmful medical errors. The malpractice environment is considered a major determinant of physicians' willingness to disclose errors to patients. Yet, little is known about the malpractice environment's actual effect on physicians' error disclosure attitudes and experiences. METHODS Mailed survey of 2637 physicians (62.9% response rate) in the Unite...
متن کاملNew York University School of Law Hauser Global Law School Program Liability Insurance Markets and the Need for Settlement Disclosure Rules: The Case of Medical Malpractice
متن کامل
Use of Nondisclosure Agreements in Medical Malpractice Settlements by a Large Academic Health Care System.
IMPORTANCE Honesty and transparency are essential aspects of health care, including in physicians' and hospitals' responses to medical error. Biases and habits associated with medical malpractice litigation, however, may work at cross-purposes with compassion in clinical care and with efforts to improve patient safety. OBJECTIVE To determine the frequency of nondisclosure agreements in medica...
متن کاملAmerican College of Medical Genetics STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES FOR CLINICAL GENETICS LABORATORIES
G1.1 In addition to numerical accession files and alphabetical patient listings, each family studied is assigned a unique code (preferably numeric). Note: This requirement only applies when more than one member of a family is being tested. (See G16.1 for maintaining confidentiality in reporting of results.) Use of a family number does not necessarily violate the confidentiality of individual fa...
متن کاملThe forgotten third: liability insurance and the medical malpractice crisis.
Although the most visible manifestations of medical malpractice involve patient safety and the legal process, the availability and affordability of liability insurance largely determine the direction of medical malpractice policy. Scientific and industrial developments since the first modern malpractice crisis in the 1970s reveal major problems with the structure and regulation of liability ins...
متن کامل